Theology matters, but not for the reason you think

My “ Theology Matters “ shirt never fails to spark conversation or earn me funny looks. But I’m sure it’s frequently misunderstood.

I’ll give you a hint: “Theology matters” is not making a statement about Christian supremacy.

Religion News Service has an article describing how many American Christians are ambivalent about social justice. Their faith doesn’t motivate them to care about the marginalization of people outside their own communities — much less act to help them.

More Than Just a Personal Relationship

We’re expected to “go and make disciples.” But that just means making sure other people are “saved” too.

This individualized faith is a modern invention. It is not the faith of the disciples, or of the early church.

When scores of people in the country’s largest religion don’t care about others, it makes an impact. And not a good one.

Theology matters.

Recognizing “Good” and “Bad” Theology

“Bad theology” is picketing military funerals and holding signs that say “God Hates Fags.”

“Bad theology” enables parents to disown their LGBT teenagers.

“Bad theology” motivates “pro-lifers” to storm abortion clinics with guns.

You get the idea. Theology matters a lot.

By contrast, “good theology” points back to Christ. Good theology builds up rather than tears down. It tells the truth with love, even when it’s uncomfortable.

Sound theology may still turn people off to the gospel, but at least it does so for the right reasons. The gospel may be offensive, but Christians themselves should not be.

Theology Matters for the Church’s Future

If we worship a God who only cares about our personal comfort, we can’t complain when people decide Christianity is not worth following.


Like this post? Please support my writing with a leave a tip via , or check out my on Amazon.

Stay in touch via and or subscribe to my monthly newsletter.

Just an author, blogger, and editor working hard so my cats can have a better life. I don’t respond to “Sarah.” View all posts by Sarahbeth Caplin

Originally published at on September 15, 2020.

Author, blogger, Anglican.